Updated Nov 19, 2026· 5 min read

Key takeaways

  • Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Timothy Hay in a 5 lb box is leafy with soft stems for rabbits and guinea pigs. See texture, feeding, storage, and fit notes.

Hay is the food small herbivores spend the most time eating, so the cut and texture of a box matter. The Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Timothy Hay in the 5 lb size offers a middle-ground texture: leafy growth, a soft stem, and a medium amount of flowery heads, rather than coarse early-harvest stems or the very soft leaf of a late harvest.

Small Pet Select describes its 2nd cutting as the standard everyday choice for healthy adult small animals, and the brand hand packs each box. This review covers what 2nd cutting means, which animals this box suits, how to store and serve it, and when a different cut or grass makes more sense.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Quick Answer

The Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Timothy Hay 5 lb box suits rabbits and guinea pigs that eat a leafy, soft-stem timothy hay well. The brand describes 2nd cutting as leafy with a medium amount of flowery heads and a texture between 1st and 3rd cutting. Choose a coarser 1st cutting, a softer 3rd cutting, or orchard hay if your animals consistently refuse this texture.

Key Specs

Spec Detail
Brand Small Pet Select
Model 2ndCutTimothy
Contents 2nd Cutting Timothy Hay only
Net weight 5 lb (2.26 kg)
Unit count 80 ounces
Cutting 2nd cutting timothy hay
Texture Leafy, soft stem, medium flowery heads
Colour Green, may include yellow or brown
Target species (listing) Rabbit, guinea pig, chinchilla, degu, tortoise
Sourcing Hay farmers in Washington State, per the brand
Packing Hand packed in a box, per the brand

Check price on Amazon

What 2nd Cutting Means

Timothy hay is harvested more than once in a growing season, and each harvest produces a different balance of leaf and stem. Small Pet Select explains that the texture and fibre of its 2nd cutting sit in between 1st and 3rd cutting, calls that balance the best of both worlds, and describes this as its most popular hay.

The first harvest tends to be stemmier and coarser, while later harvests tend to be softer and leafier. A 2nd cutting aims at the middle: enough stem to feel like proper hay, with more leaf and flowery heads mixed through. The brand notes that the hay is green but may be mixed with yellow or brown depending on weather and growing conditions, and that this is normal.

Feeding and Daily Use

Small Pet Select positions hay as the foundation of the daily diet for rabbits and guinea pigs, and its guidance stresses that animals should not run out of hay. It also recommends offering a fresh supply at least once a day.

How hay is offered affects how much gets eaten. The brand suggests keeping hay contained and off the habitat floor, for example in a hay manger, so less is stepped on or soiled. The 5 lb size sits in the middle of the range the brand sells: manageable for one or two guinea pigs, or a single rabbit, to finish while it stays fresh.

Storage and Handling

Hay keeps best when it stays dry. The brand advises storing it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Keep the box off a damp floor and close it between uses where the packaging allows.

Who It’s For

This hay fits owners of adult rabbits and guinea pigs who want a labelled, everyday timothy hay with a leafy, soft-stem texture. It also suits owners who find that a coarse 1st cutting gets picked through and wasted, but who still want some stem and flower heads. The listing also names chinchillas, degus, and tortoises, so multi-species homes should check each animal’s needs first.

Who Should Skip It

Skip this box if your animals leave soft, leafy hay and eat coarse stems first; those animals are usually better matched to a stemmier 1st cutting. Very picky animals that refuse stems may do better on a softer 3rd cutting.

Households with a timothy sensitivity may also look elsewhere, since Small Pet Select points people who react to timothy hay toward orchard hay. Owners feeding young, pregnant, or unwell animals should confirm the right hay type rather than assuming an adult maintenance hay fits every stage. Skip the 5 lb box, too, if there is no dry storage space for it.

How It Compares With Alternatives

Compared with 1st cutting timothy, this 2nd cutting is softer and leafier, while 1st cutting is the coarser, stem-first choice. Compared with 3rd cutting, it keeps more stem and structure, while 3rd cutting is generally the softest and leafiest. None is universally better; the right one is the one an animal eats steadily and in quantity.

Compared with orchard grass, timothy is the traditional staple, while orchard is a different grass some owners use for variety or when timothy bothers people at home. Compared with unlabelled store hay, the difference here is transparency: the cutting is named and the box is hand packed rather than compressed.

FAQ

What does 2nd cutting timothy hay mean?

It is hay from the second harvest of the season. Small Pet Select describes it as leafy with a soft stem and a medium amount of flowery heads, between 1st and 3rd cutting in texture.

Which animals is this 5 lb box intended for?

It is aimed at rabbits and guinea pigs, and the listing also names chinchillas, degus, and tortoises. Introduce any new hay gradually alongside the hay the animal already eats.

How should the hay be stored after opening?

In a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight, with the box off damp floors and closed between uses where possible. Refresh the hay offered daily and remove soiled strands.

Why does the hay contain yellow or brown strands?

The brand explains that the hay is green but may be mixed with yellow or brown depending on weather and growing conditions, and that this variation is normal.

Final Verdict

The Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Timothy Hay 5 lb box is a well-judged everyday hay for rabbits and guinea pigs: a leafy, soft-stem middle texture, a clearly labelled cutting, and a size one or two animals can finish while it stays fresh. For owners who want a repeatable staple hay and have dry storage, it is a sound main hay.

A
admin
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Timothy Hay 5…Check price on Amazon